The Stephen King Adaptation That Is Nothing Like the Book

September 2024 · 6 minute read

The Big Picture

There are very few constants in this world, but adaptations of Stephen King's work are definitely one of them. The author's had a prolific set of novels that have been adapted into multiple films and television series across the years, to varying degrees of success. Some are highly regarded, like Stanley Kubrick'sThe Shining (despite King's well-founded hatred of the film). Others, like The Tommyknockers, have been consigned to the dust bin of memory. No matter the text being adapted, it will split viewers down the middle, whether you're a dedicated movie lover or a fan of King's work. A large part of this is due to the fact that most of these adaptations veer sharply away from the source material, and that trend continued with 2017's The Dark Tower.

The Dark Tower was unique among King adaptations for a number of reasons. It was based on the series that King considered to be his "magnum opus", mainly because of its vast connections to his other work. It had legit star power in the form of Idris Elba and Matthew McConaughey. Most importantly, it served as the culmination of a decades-long effort to bring The Dark Tower to the screen as everyone from J.J. Abrams to Ron Howard had taken a stab at trying to secure the film rights. But what makes the film special is the fact that it actually serves as a sequel of sorts to the actual Dark Tower books.

The Dark Tower
PG-13

A boy haunted by visions of a dark tower from a parallel reality teams up with the tower's disillusioned guardian to stop an evil warlock known as the Man in Black who plans to use the boy to destroy the tower and open the gates of Hell.

Release Date August 3, 2017 Director Nikolaj Arcel Cast Katheryn Winnick , Matthew McConaughey , Idris Elba , Abbey Lee , Jackie Earle Haley , Dennis Haysbert Runtime 95 Main Genre Action Production Company Columbia Pictures, MRC, Imagine Entertainment, Weed Road Pictures Expand

The Dark Tower Film Leans Into The Multiversal Connections Of The Original Novel

The main plot of The Dark Tower centers on Roland Deschain, the last of the warriors known as the "Gunslingers". Supernaturally skilled with guns, Deschain has been in hard pursuit of Walter O'Dim, aka the Man in Black – the mysterious sorcerer who's been influencing his life at a young age. Their quest brings them into the vicinity of the titular Dark Tower, which serves as the nexus of all reality. In the final book, The Dark Tower, Deschain learns that he has actually reached the Tower multiple times, but has been forced to relive his journey until he can depend on others. He is sent back one final time with a special object in his hand: the Horn of Eld. Passed down throughout the centuries, the Horn was supposed to be in Roland's care until he abandoned it in a crucial battle.

When The Dark Tower was announced, King posted a picture on Twitter (now known as X) of the Horn of Eld with the following caption: "Last Time Around". Director Nikolaj Arcel would later confirm that the Dark Tower film was indeed a sequel to the novels, "It is, in fact, a continuation,” he said in an interview with IGN. "It is a canon continuation. That’s exactly what we intended and what Stephen King has signed off on.” Making The Dark Tower an official continuation of the books was a solid move on two fronts. It allowed for an entirely new story to be told that was both free of having to follow the books but didn't entirely overwrite them either. It also allowed Arcel to focus the film on one of Deschain's earlier relationships with the young psychic Jake Chambers (Tom Taylor). In the first Dark Tower novel, The Gunslinger, Deschain sacrifices Jake to a pit in order to continue pursuing the Man in Black. But in the film, he forms a fatherly bond with the boy, risking life and limb to protect him.

Matthew McConaughey's Villain Connects The Dark Tower To All Of Stephen King's Work

The Dark Tower kept one crucial aspect from the novels: the bitter rivalry between Deschain and the Man in Black. The latter was known by many names, including Walter O'Dim and Marten Broadcloak, but fans of King's work may know him by another name: Randall Flagg. Flagg has appeared in King's other works, particularly his post-apocalyptic novel The Stand, causing death and destruction wherever he goes. His many names, as well as his immense power, serve as a reflection of how The Dark Tower connects all of King's work. He's tormented numerous victims – including Roland, as Flagg seduced his mother and led his father to an early death.

Ironically, though McConaughey would portray the Man in Black in The Dark Tower, he was tapped to play a critical role in another King adaptation. Josh Boone was tapped to adapt The Stand for Warner Bros, and he revealed that he wanted McConaughey to play Stu Redman while Christian Bale would play Flagg. The adaptation never manifested due to the rights reverting back to CBS Films. Eventually, The Stand would be adapted as a miniseries on Paramount+ with Alexander Skarsgård stepping into Flagg's leather boots. McConaughey still manages to convey a fair amount of affable menace in The Dark Tower, providing the perfect contrast to Elba's stoic gunslinger.

The Dark Tower's Changes Didn't Help Its Box Office Chances

Close

Despite King signing off on the film, the star power of Elba & McConaughey, and its summer release date, The Dark Tower was a critical and commercial dud. A number of factors fed into its lukewarm reception, including a far too short running time as well as a failure to lean into the more memorable aspects of King's books. But the biggest sin is that the film never leans into the promise of exploring Roland's final journey. This was a man who had to learn to rely on others, to forgo vengeance in search of actual justice. With an actor of Elba's caliber, this could have made for some weighty storytelling. Instead, audiences were treated to a run-of-the-mill fantasy/Western.

Related
Now Is the Perfect Time To Remake the Only Movie Stephen King Directed

It's time for the Green Goblin truck to come out of semi-retirement.

The saga of the Gunslinger may yet be done justice, as Mike Flanagan is slated to adapt The Dark Tower for television. Not only has Flanagan received King's stamp of approval, but he's also helmed two previous King adaptations, Gerald's Game and Doctor Sleep. Flanagan knows his way around a King adaptation, so hopefully he can make any necessary changes while still keeping the spirit of the Dark Tower books intact.

The Dark Tower is available to rent or buy on Apple TV+ in the U.S.

WATCH ON APPLE TV+

ncG1vNJzZmibn6G5qrDEq2Wcp51kwLWxz6Gcp2WbnruoedOhnGackae4bsDOsJyrZZ2kw6qxjJumqKNdlrGivNOaq6KnnmQ%3D